Following shortly behind the popular GameMastery Module Open Call contest in 2007, Paizo announced that it would be holding an even larger contest which would involve six rounds of competition and allow for fan voting entitled RPG Superstar. Specific challenges included designing a wondrous item, a country, a villain, three thematically linked monsters, an encounter, and finally an adventure synopsis.
From October 31, 2007 to February 11, 2008, judges Wolfgang Baur, Erik Mona, and Clark Peterson narrowed a field of over 850 contestants down to the Top 32, 16, 8, and 4 before the final winner was announced.
- See also: RPG Superstar
The Top 4 contestants were announced on January 30, 2008. Each entrant submitted an adventure proposal for public voting to determine the winner of the contest.
Round Four called for the Top 8 to design three thematically linked monsters. Six RPG Superstar contestants were selected by the voting public to move on to the penultimate round of RPG Superstar. The voting public seemed willing to follow the lead of the judges this round and voted out the two contestants that received the lowest overall scores from Erik Mona, Clark Peterson, and Wolfgang Baur.
Joe Outzen Russ Taylor
Paizo Publishing announced on January 3, 2008 the eight RPG Superstar contestants who were selected by the voting public to move on to Round Four. This round focused on the creation and design of a unique character to fill the role of villain in any campaign.
Neil McClean Joseph Yerger
The 16 RPG Superstar contestants who were selected by the voting public to move on to round three were announced on December 12, 2007. After reading the recommendations of the judges, the Paizo messageboard community decided by vote which entrants would advance to the next round. It was a close race with the 17th finalist missing the top 16 by just a handful of votes.
Erik Anderson Hal Maclean Andrew Black Alexander MacLeod Samuel Kisko William McNulty James MacKenzie Walter Pullen
For the initial open call, more than 850 entrants submitted a wondrous item using the 3.5 SRD. Each entry needed to be 200 words or less and had to include proper mechanics and flavor. From this pool, the Top 32 finalists were selected to write a 1,000-word description of a fantasy nation covering that nation's people, history, geography, government and hidden secrets. 
Jeb Boyt Robert McRae Ross Byers Dwayne Monroe William Cronk Daniele Nanni Laurens de Haan Chris Nichols Chad Patterson Mauricio Quintana Joel Flank Michael Raper Alex Handley Rennie Saunders Michael Kogan Viktor Svindland Silas McDermott
- ↑ Paizo Publishing. (October 30, 2007). RPG Superstar Will Find the Next Great RPG Designer, Paizo News.
- ↑ Paizo Publishing. (February 20, 2008). Christine Schneider Wins Paizo's First RPG Superstar™!, Paizo News.
- ↑ Paizo Publishing. (January 30, 2008). RPG Superstar Final Four Announced, Paizo News.
- ↑ Paizo Publishing. (January 16, 2008). RPG Superstar Round Four Results Announced, Paizo News.
- ↑ Paizo Publishing. (January 3, 2008). RPG Superstar Round Three Results Announced, Paizo News.
- ↑ Paizo Publishing. (December 12, 2007). RPG Superstar Round Two Results Announced, Paizo News.
- ↑ Paizo Publishing. (November 28, 2007). [hhttp://paizo.com/paizo/news/v5748eaic9kve RPG Superstar Top 32 Announced], Paizo News.